Island Grilling Night - Citrusy Garlic Steak with Fresh Mango Salsa – Bold, Juicy, Unforgettable

Fire up your grill for Island Grilling Night with my Citrusy Garlic Steak with Fresh Mango Salsa.  It’s bold, breezy, and bursting with tropical flavor—your perfect summer dinner idea!

Citrusy Garlic Steak with Fresh Mango Salsa – Bold, Juicy, Unforgettable

Lately, I’ve been in an island flavor kind of mood—craving bright citrus, juicy tropical fruit, and a touch of heat. Our wedding anniversary is coming up in August, and every year around this time, I find myself reminiscing about that magical trip to Hawaii. The warm breeze, the ocean views, the bold, vibrant food—it all left a lasting impression. And while this dish has a Cuban flair, it still brings me right back to that tropical feeling we love so much.

This Citrusy Garlic Steak with Fresh Mango Salsa is a delicious mash-up of bold island flavors. The steak gets a garlicky-citrus rub inspired by Cuban seasoning blends—zesty, savory, and perfect for the grill. Then it’s topped with a mango salsa that’s bright, sweet, and spicy, just like the fruit stands we used to pass in North Shore. It’s a little bit of Cuba, a little bit of Hawaii, and 100% a summer dinner worth repeating.

Whether you're dreaming of your next island vacation or just looking to spice up steak night, this recipe brings a fresh, tropical twist to the table. Bold, juicy, and unforgettable—just the way summer should taste..

Enjoy!

🛒 What You’ll Need – Island Grilling Night Shopping List

Produce

• 2 large or 3 small ripe mangoes

• 2 jalapeños

• ½ medium red onion

• ½ lime

• Fresh cilantro (about ½ cup loosely packed leaves)

• Red Bell Pepper

Meat

• 1 to 1½ lb sirloin steak

Pantry & Seasonings

• Olive oil

• Kosher salt

• Trader Joe’s Cuban Style Citrusy Garlic Seasoning Blend (or similar citrus-garlic blend)

🍍 Perfect Pairings – Optional Sides & Sips for Your Island-Inspired Feast

Whether you're going all-out for a tropical dinner party or just adding a few extras to your plate, these sides and drinks bring the vibe full circle:

Sides

• Coconut Lime Rice – Creamy, fragrant, and the perfect bed for that mango salsa.

• Grilled Pineapple Spears – Lightly charred and caramelized for a sweet finish.

• Crispy Plantain Chips – Great for scooping up extra salsa.

• Avocado-Cucumber Salad – Cool and creamy with a citrusy vinaigrette.

• Black Beans with Garlic & Cilantro – Savory and grounding with island flair.

• Toasted Hawaiian Rolls – A fun, buttery nod to Hawaiian BBQ.

Drinks

• Sparkling Limeade – Refreshing and tart with a fizzy finish.

• Virgin Piña Coladas or Mojitos – Coconut, mint, and citrus—pick your favorite island classic.

• Tropical Iced Tea – Brew black tea with pineapple juice and a hint of mint.

• Fresh Mango Smoothies – Especially fun if you're serving this as a summer brunch-for-dinner.

Substitutions and Variations

Substitutions

Need to make a few adjustments? These simple substitutions will keep the bold, juicy, tropical flavors front and center:

• Steak Substitute:
  Try flank steak or skirt steak if sirloin isn’t available. Just adjust the cook time and slice thinly against the grain.

• Seasoning Swap:
  No Trader Joe’s Cuban Style Citrusy Garlic Blend? Use a mix of garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, dried oregano, cumin, and a little orange and lime zest.

• Fruit Alternative:
  Can’t find ripe mangoes? Use pineapple or papaya for a similar tropical sweetness and texture.

• Herb Option:
  Swap parsley or mint for cilantro if you’re not a fan—both still keep things fresh and vibrant.

• Heat Level Adjustment:
  Use Fresno chiles or even poblano peppers instead of jalapeños for less spice and more crunch.

Variations

This bold and juicy steak with mango salsa is just the beginning—here are a few tasty ways to spin it based on what you’re craving or how you’re serving it:

• Tropical Steak Tacos:  Slice the steak thin and tuck it into warm corn tortillas with mango salsa, shredded cabbage, and a drizzle of lime crema or chipotle mayo. Instant taco night with an island twist!

• Island Steak Bowls:  Serve the steak and salsa over a bed of coconut rice, quinoa, or mixed greens. Add black beans, avocado slices, and a handful of crushed plantain chips for crunch.

• Grilled Chicken or Shrimp Option:  Not in a steak mood? This mango salsa pairs just as beautifully with grilled chicken thighs or citrus-marinated shrimp. Perfect for a lighter or seafood-forward dinner.

• Make It a Salad:  Turn everything into a hearty salad! Slice the steak over a bed of romaine or baby greens, top with mango salsa, avocado, and a lime vinaigrette for a fresh, vibrant meal.

Kitchen Tips and Notes

A few simple tips to help you get the most flavor and ease out of this tropical dinner:

• Let the Steak Rest:  After searing, let the steak rest for at least 5–10 minutes before slicing. This helps lock in the juices and gives you a more tender bite.

• Choose Ripe Mangoes:  Look for mangoes that give slightly when pressed and smell sweet at the stem. .

• Prep Ahead for Ease:  You can make the mango salsa up to a few hours in advance—just cover and chill. The flavors only get better!

• Watch the Heat:  Want more or less spice? Keep some jalapeño seeds for extra heat, or substitute with bell pepper for a milder bite. You’re in control.

• Cast Iron for the Win:  A hot cast iron skillet gives you that perfect steak sear and crust. No grill? No problem—this pan brings the heat indoors.

HUNGRY FOR MORE? Subscribe to emails at the top of this page and follow along on Facebook,  and Pinterest for all of the latest updates.